Financial CHFP : Certified Healthcare Financial Professional (CHFP) - 2021 Exam
Exam Dumps Organized by Richard
Latest December 2021 Updated Syllabus
Dumps | Complete question bank with real Questions
Real Questions from New Course of CHFP - Updated Daily - 100% Pass Guarantee
Question : Download 100% Free CHFP Dumps PDF and VCE
Exam Number : CHFP
Exam Name : Certified Healthcare Financial Professional (CHFP) - 2021
Vendor Name : Financial
Update : Click Here to Check Latest Update
Question Bank : Check Questions
Download and install CHFP Latest Topics with valid real questions.
killexams.com is a reliable and true platform who have provide CHFP PDF Download along with 100% pass guarantee. You'll want to practice CHFP questions to get atlest round the clock to score effectively in the CHFP exam. Your individual real voyage to pass in Certified Healthcare Financial Professional (CHFP) - 2021 exam, undoubtedly starts along with killexams.com CHFP PDF Braindumps.
Financial CHFP test
objective should be to clear your individual concepts around core models of Certified Healthcare Financial Professional (CHFP) - 2021. Simply just CHFP path books find it difficult to do this endeavor. You have to work tirelessly to get perception of CHFP challenging topics. It is advisable to go to killexams.com for you to obtain Absolutely free CHFP braindumps questions and even read comprehensively. If you feel that anyone can retain the CHFP questions, you should get a hold of full PDF Download of CHFP Free test
PDF. That will be very first great advancement toward development. obtain and install VCE practice test in your DESKTOP. Memorize and even understand CHFP Free test
PDF and even take train test as far as possible with VCE practice test. When you feel like you are well prepared for realistic CHFP exam, register for realistic test.
Things about Killexams CHFP Free test
-> Instant CHFP Free test
PDF get a hold of Access
-> Complete CHFP Questions and Answers
-> 98% Results Rate for CHFP Exam
-> Guaranteed Authentic CHFP test
-> CHFP Questions Up graded on Regular basis.
-> Applicable CHFP test
-> hundred percent Portable CHFP test
-> Full shown CHFP VCE test
-> Unlimited CHFP test
obtain and install Access
-> Fantastic Discount Coupons
-> hundred percent Secured obtain and install Account
-> hundred percent Confidentiality Ascertained
-> 100% Results Guarantee
-> hundred percent Free Free PDF for check-up
-> No Disguised . Cost
-> Not any Monthly Costs
-> No Computerized Account Repair
-> CHFP test
Update Intimation by E mail
-> Free Technical Support
Exam Element at: https://killexams.com/pass4sure/exam-detail/CHFP
Price Details within: https://killexams.com/exam-price-comparison/CHFP
See Finish List: https://killexams.com/vendors-exam-list
Discount Coupon code on Maximum CHFP Free test
PDF PDF Download;
WC2020: 60% Flat Low cost on each exam
PROF17: 10% Further Low cost on Valuation Greater compared to $69
DEAL17: 15% More Discount about Value A lot more than $99
Format | CHFP Course Contents | CHFP Course Outline | CHFP test
Syllabus | CHFP test
Module I - Business of Health Care: Participation and successful end-of-course assessment of the HFMA Business of Health Care® online program offering participants an overview of healthcare finance, risk mitigation, evolving payment models, healthcare accounting and cost analysis, strategic finance, and managing financial resources.
Module II - Operational Excellence: CHFP aspirants must also complete HFMA's Operational Excellence exam, which includes exercises and case studies on the application of business acumen in health care.
Please note HFMA membership is a required aspect for earning and maintaining the CHFP credential.
Paid student members are eligible to register for and to take both modules of the CHFP certification program (included with membership). Student members who successfully complete the CHFP requirements (two modules) will earn their designation upon assuming Professional or Business Partner level member status.
The Big Picture Healthcare environment
- Reform/Current State of US Healthcare
- Transformation Under Reform
- Payment System Overview
- The Role of Financial Management in Health Care Organizations
- Management Roles & Hierarchy
- What Keeps CFOs Up at Night=>
Financial Accounting Concepts Accounting Principles
- Analysis of Financial Statements
- Management Reports
- Accounting Terminology
- Reports for financial analysis
Cost Analysis Principles Cost Management
- Traditional Cost-Finding Methods
- Setting Prices
- Profit analysis
Strategic Financial Issues Basics of Strategic Planning
- Budgeting Concepts
- Variance Analysis
- Revenue & Performance Budgeting
- Controlling Operating Results
- Benchmarking, Productivity, and Cost-Benefit/Cost-Effectiveness
Managing Financial Resources Financing the Healthcare System: Revenue Cycle
- Working capital management
- The Use of Metrics and Data
- Long-Term Financial Resources
Looking to the Future ACA, ACOs & Bundled Payments:
The Need for Business Intelligence & Analytics
Population Health Management
Aligning Clinicians and Finance Professionals to Drive Value
Accountable Care Organizations – Payer Cancers
Premium Growth in a Shifting Environment
Denials of coverage
Limitations on profits
Health Insurance Exchanges
Rise of Business Process Outsourcing
Consumerism and physicians
Physician –Hospital alignment
Demand for Physician Collegiality
Emerging Ancillary Positions
Physician Shortages (Leakage)
Physicians as Entrepreneurs
Reform and Physician Liability
Physician – Hospital Financial
Hospital – Physician Alignment
Hospital Facing Bankruptcy
Provider- Payer Consolidations
Physician Engagement and Leadership
Integrated Care Delivery
Accountable Care Organizations
Sustainability of Physician
Module I Concept Guide – It is recommended that you preview this guide prior to working through the online materials. For example, the pages in this guide associated with the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA) may be viewed before working in the first course, Healthcare Finance -- The Big Picture. This preview indicates the key concepts that will be covered and attunes you to areas of professional practice that may be less familiar. Feel free to make notes in this document. By taking the time to customize this guide, you can develop a handy reference tool as you continue your work in health care.
• Module II Concept Guide - It is recommended that candidates preview the key=> concept guide prior to working through this online course. The module is itself an examination with three (3) hours allowed for completion. This preview indicates the key business challenges that will be presented and attunes candidates to areas of professional practice that may be less familiar. The learner guide can then be used to focus additional outside memorizing and study on unfamiliar issues
Killexams Review | Reputation | Testimonials | Feedback
It is great idea to read CHFP test
Using the usage of marvelous products involving killexams.com, I put scored 92% marks with CHFP certification. I was seeking a reliable examination dump to enhance my know-how. Technical principles and the tricky language involving my certification changed into difficult to understand as being a I develop into in search of the dependable as well as valid examination product. I put come to identify this web site for the instruction of qualified certification. Them changed into uncomplicated Answers to me. I am sensation right for my favorite success and this also platform is decent for me.
Are you able to accept as true with, all CHFP questions I organized had been asked.
I just looked for your dumps which in turn fulfill the precise wants at the CHFP test
dumps. The killexams. com dumps in reality bumped out my doubts in the brief time frame. First time at my career, I just attend the particular CHFP test
with a lot less than one assistance material and turn into successful by using extremely good marks. I am undoubtedly satisfied, even so the motive On the web here in order to congratulate you actually on the great help you supplied in the form of an experiment dump.
Where will I locate Questions and Answers to have a study CHFP exam?
exam for being less difficult. killexams. com includes saved their money and time, those CHFP dumps Questions and also Answers Rankings have hit a brick wall the CHFP exam. I obtained panic about very few questions, therefore i nearly were required to bet, even so that is their fault. I've got to have commited to memory well and also listened to often the questions far better. Nevermind, I just passed often the CHFP test
with superb scores.
I am very happy with this CHFP study guide.
My parents explained their testimonies that they familiar with study extremely seriously in addition to passed their own test
in the first endeavor and each of their parents by no means bothered regarding their schooling and occupation building. Together with due regard, I would like individuals them that have been they taking CHFP test
and facing the avalanche of courses and analyze guides which confuse scholars during their test
studies. Typically the answer are going to be NO . These days you cannot elope from these kinds of certifications by CHFP test
even after doing your standard education and what to converse of a occupation building. Typically the prevailing evaluation is cut-throat. However , you don't need to to worry due to the fact killexams. com questions in addition to answers is there which is ok to take the scholars to the point regarding test
with full confidence and confidence of driving CHFP exam. Thanks a great deal to the killexams. com crew otherwise they need to be scolding by each of their parents in addition to listening to their own success stories.
That was incredible! I got real test questions updated CHFP exam.
I had formed to pass the CHFP test
in addition to passing quality was a very difficult action to take. killexams. com helped me with gaining calm, calmness and using their own CHFP braindumps to prepare myself personally for the analyze. The CHFP test
simulator was very beneficial and I surely could pass the particular CHFP test
and got endorsed in my provider.
Financial 2021 test
December 03, 2021
New Accounting Framework Faces Its First test: CECL during the Pandemic
Bert Loudis, Sasha Pechenik, Ben Ranish, Cindy M. Vojtech, and Helen Xu1
On January 1, 2020, most massive and mid-sized U.S. banks adopted existing anticipated credit score Losses (CECL), a brand new accounting typical for estimating allowances.2 Allowance for credit losses is an estimate of the quantity that a financial institution is not likely to Excellerate from a monetary asset. CECL was issued to exchange the incurred loss methodology (ILM) as coverage makers determined that the raise in allowances passed off too late within the enterprise cycle under ILM. by means of altering the timing and degree of allowances, CECL also influences the timing and level of capital, which could influence lending.
often, loan losses (also known as web can charge-offs) build when unemployment increases and GDP slows.three This relationship is clear all the way through the 2007â€“09 economic crisis shown in figure 1. just a number of months after CECL turned into adopted, the financial system fell into a sharp decline because the COVID-19 pandemic resulted in common disruption to enterprise activities (figure 1, March 2020). This coincidence turned into a right away verify of the CECL methodology all through an financial downturn and recuperation, albeit an peculiar one.
determine 1. Banking equipment Quarterly web cost-off expense with economic indications
When a financial institution builds allowances through provision expense, web income is reduced and that reduces capital. because of this, as capital is commonly regarded a costly funding source, loans that carry higher allowances below CECL (as compared to ILM) become more costly to underwrite.4 In response, banks may additionally alternate their lending practices. This observe estimates how CECL modified allowances and capital, and additional explores the connection between CECL and lending boom. as a result of only a part of the banking system turned into originally area to CECL, the analysis compares banks that adopted CECL on January 1, 2020 (CECL adopters) and banks that remained in ILM as of June 30, 2021 (non-adopters) to estimate these outcomes.5
Our evaluation suggests that CECL adopters' allowances spoke back extra at once than non-adopters to changes within the economic outlook. furthermore, they demonstrate that while CECL multiplied combination allowances, the combination capital affect has been largely neutralized via the regulatory capital transition rule.6 They display that CECL has had a big range of influence on allowances for diverse loan kinds. besides the fact that children, they locate confined proof that the impact of CECL on allowances is associated with decreased lending within the pandemic.
ILM accounting normal limits banks' means to provision for losses that aren't yet likely. The fiscal disaster of 2007-2009 Checked
gigantic issues with this challenge. In certain, banks had low stages of allowances to soak up credit score losses within the lead up to the fiscal disaster. as the disaster unfolded, banks multiplied provisions for in all likelihood loan losses. This put additional drive on financial institution capital, which became already being depleted as a result of different losses throughout the crisis.
figure 2 shows this "too little, too late" relationship. Provisions (solid tremendous bars) sharply increase most effective after the recession has begun and net cost-offs raise (hole terrible bars). Provisions outpace internet charge-offs to build allowances (black line), with allowances peaking round 2010, after the recession has ended.
figure 2. Provision and web charge-off fees across the 2007-09 monetary disaster
To handle this difficulty, various stakeholders requested that the accounting normal-setters, the FASB and overseas Accounting specifications Board, work to include extra forward-looking information in requisites on mortgage loss provisioning. In response, the FASB issued a new accounting regular in June 2016 that brought the CECL methodology for estimating allowances for credit score losses.
In comparison to ILM, CECL requires banks to believe forward-looking guidance and record a provision for anticipated losses over the total life of the loan when the mortgage is originated. CECL doesn't change the whole quantity of credit losses that will be in the end recorded in economic statements, nonetheless it impacts how early the bank provisions for credit losses. as a result of CECL allowances represent an estimate of lifetime lossesâ€”as adversarial to losses over a typically shorter "loss emergence period" under ILMâ€”CECL commonly effects in a more robust stage of allowances at each reporting duration.
CECL's have an impact on on Allowances within the Pandemic
due to the COVID-19 pandemic, many households and companies faced a sudden lack of earnings. at the equal time, wonderful fiscal and monetary policy guide blunted the monetary stress. This area examines the ameliorations in credit score loss provisioning for CECL adopters and non-adopters all the way through this peculiar and highly unclear atmosphere.
determine three compares the evolution of allowances for CECL adopters and non-adopters. Allowances of both sets of banks had been solid in 2019, reflecting low and solid web cost-off charges. The adoption of CECL resulted in an instantaneous 37 percent raise in adopters' allowances on January 1, 2020. This impact represents an general normal difference in allowances between CECL and ILM under the frequently benign economic outlook that existed on January 1, 2020. From that element onwards, the adoption of CECL and the onset of the pandemic both affected provisioning.
because the pandemic wired the financial system, CECL adopters rapidly multiplied loss provisions. now not counting the adoption have an impact on, allowances elevated by means of 76 % within the first half of 2020 relative to 2019:this autumn levels. In comparison, non-adopters' allowances improved by most effective 32 % over the equal period. After peaking in 2020:Q2, CECL adopters' allowances begin to say no with growth within the economic outlook. Non-adopters' allowances peaked in 2020:this autumn, and have most effective declined a bit due to the fact that then. As of 2021:Q2, the difference in allowances between CECL adopters and non-adopters is lower back to the place it became automatically after CECL adoption.
determine 3. Allowances of CECL Adopters and Non-Adopters
desk 1 shows that the have an impact on of CECL on allowances varies significantly across loan types, introduced in descending order of their share of total allowances in 2019:q4.7 Column (1) gives the January 1, 2020 adoption impact.eight consumer mortgage forms that are inclined to have higher credit losses (e.g., credit cards) or longer maturities (e.g., student loans and auto) had the biggest raises in allowances at CECL adoption. Columns (2) and (3) display allowance adjustments within the first half of 2020, as the financial outlook worsened. Allowances of all mortgage kinds improved materially throughout this duration, with CECL adopters' allowances expanding extra swiftly than non-adopters in every respective portfolio. Columns (four) and (5) show adjustments in allowances between June 2020 and June 2021 when the financial outlook incessantly more advantageous. all the way through this length, CECL adopters considerably decreased their allowances throughout portfolios whereas non-adopters' complete allowances stayed relatively flat in combination. At both adopter and non-adopter banks, decreases in allowances during this length had been larger for customer than wholesale loans. Allowances most effective persisted to boost for the commercial true estate portfolio, which may also have been adversely plagued by the lingering results of the pandemic on workplace occupancy prices.
while there are tremendous alterations between the ordinary CECL adopter and non-adopter that might account for one of the most divergence described above, the pandemic journey suggests that CECL frequently raises the responsiveness of provisioning for credit losses to changes in economic outlook.
table 1: exchange in Allowances, through personal loan classification
percentage change in Allowances Relative to Dec 31, 2019
On Jan 1, 2020
Jan 1, 2020 - June 30, 2020
June 30, 2020 â€“ June 30, 2021
Estimates of CECL's Capital affect in the Pandemic
determine 4 indicates the evolution of combination average equity tier 1 (CET1) capital ratio for CECL adoptersâ€”each including (solid black line) and aside from (dashed blue line) the influence of the transition rule.9 With most organisations the use of the transition rule, the mixture capital ratio declined via about 50 groundwork points to eleven.three % in 2020:Q1, and climbed thereafter, attaining 12.5 percent in 2021:Q2. The transition rule improved the ratio via about 30 to 40 basis features, depending on the quarter.
To check the affect of CECL, they first estimate what would have happened to CECL adopters' allowancesâ€”and for this reason their capitalâ€”if they had remained on ILM. They use records on non-adopter banks to estimate a linear regression touching on allowance-to-personal loan ratios in every quarter to financial institution and personal loan characteristics. Then, they use this mannequin to foretell what the allowances of CECL adopters would had been if they had remained on ILM.10 each dollar change in allowances is transformed into a negative seventy nine cent change in capital under the assumption of a 21 p.c corporate tax expense. In their estimate, they also count on that CECL had no effect on the dollar quantity of web capital distributions (e.g., dividends and share repurchases).
The black dashed traces within the determine characterize a range of estimates for what CECL adopters' aggregate capital ratio would have been beneath ILM. This range is the middle 95 percent of combination capital ratios that outcome from operating this regression mannequin on many random samples of the non-adopters, with the dimension of the latitude reflecting uncertainty in how the evolution of allowances pertains to banks' features.
Our estimates suggest that the transition rule about neutralized the aggregate capital have an effect on of CECL to this point, with the mixture capital of CECL adopters falling within or just beneath the latitude of estimated effects under ILM. however, as counseled with the aid of table 1, the transition rule may no longer have neutralized the capital impact of CECL throughout loan types.
determine 4. Capital (CET1) Ratios of Jan. 1 CECL Adopters, genuine versus Estimates under ILM
CECL influence on Lending within the Pandemic
whereas the pandemic gives facts that CECL presents less of a "too little, too late" subject, commenters on CECL have suggested that the regular may end up in tighter financial institution credit score supply when it is in top-rated want.11 The generally bigger allowance beneath CECL reduces capital, inflicting banks to lift or retain extra capital in order to maintain their capital buffers. As capital is considered a more costly funding supply, this doubtlessly raises personal loan funding expenses. due to this fact, they might expect CECL adopters to in the reduction of the type of lending with increases in allowances beneath CECL. despite the fact, handiest the diverse "different buyer" loan classification experienced a statistically large reduce in lending at CECL adopters relative to non-adopters. additionally, as they talk about further, this change in increase is intricate to attribute to CECL adoption given the pre-latest change in other customer personal loan boom trends across both types of banks.
To formally investigate the relationship between CECL's influences on allowances and mortgage increase, they follow the smartly-based difference-in-adjustments methodology. during this formula, the effects of handled (CECL adopters indicated by $$CECL_i = 1$$) banks are in comparison to the outcomes of untreated banks (non-adopters), before and after the medication occurs (submit-CECL adoption indicated via $$Post_t = 1$$). This assessment is made separately for each and every personal loan classification $$p$$ for which granular statistics on allowances are available, the use of banks $$i$$ over quarters $$t$$ (2016:Q1-2021:Q2) the use of the specification below:
$$$$ personal loan\ increase_p,i,t = \beta_p Post_t * CECL_i + \sum_n=1^three \gamma_p,n Delinq_p,n,i,t + \delta_p,t + \theta_p,i + \varepsilon_p,i,t $$$$
$$$$ Allowance/Loans_p,i,t = \beta_p Post_t * CECL_i + \sum_n=1^3 \gamma_p,n Delinq_p,n,i,t + \delta_p,t + \theta_p,i + \varepsilon_p,i,t $$$$
word the regression necessities contains additional controls: three delinquency rates ($$Delinq_p,n,i,t$$), financial institution-certain fixed results $$\theta_p,i$$, and quarterly fastened effects $$\delta_p,t$$.12 below the idea that CECL adoption is the only final reason for effects (allowances or loan boom) to alternate differently for adopters and non-adopters after Jan 1, 2020, the coefficient $$\beta_p$$ equals the normal effect of CECL on mortgage growth or additional allowances for mortgage category $$p$$.
This difference-in-ameliorations assumptionâ€”and for this reason their estimates of CECL affectâ€”is more likely to be legitimate when the adopter and non-adopter banks are an identical. for that reason, they eliminate banks with ordinary business fashions, as smartly because the biggest (generally CECL adopters) and smallest (basically non-adopters) from their regression sample.13 They also observe filters to get rid of immaterial business strains and limit the function of outliers.14 As only a few banks in their trial
have fabric card portfolios, they exclude cards from the analysis.15 at last, they verify the plausibility of the difference-in-adjustments assumption by means of checking out whether CECL adopters and non-adopters faced an identical loan increase traits prior to CECL adoption. The check rejects the speculation that CECL adopters and non-adopters' "different customer" personal loan growth followed the identical style ahead of CECL adoption, which casts doubt on the validity of the assessment of these loans throughout the two units of banks.16
The outcomes of their regressions are summarized in determine 5, with the corresponding regression tables in the appendix (desk A.1 Panel A and B). The values of $$\beta_p$$â€”the average estimated consequences of CECL on allowances and loan growthâ€”are represented with the aid of the coordinates of the plotted circles, with each circle representing a specific loan type. The y-axis price is the effect on loan boom, and the x-axis value is the effect on allowances. The dashed crosshairs represent statistical 95 percent confidence intervals for these estimates.
figure 5. Estimated standard CECL impact ($$\beta_p$$) on Allowances and loan boom, via loan category
All five circles can be found some distance adequate to the correct of the vertical axis that their crosshairs do not move itâ€”indicating that the common have an impact on of CECL on allowances of each loan category was fantastic and statistically giant. If CECL's have an effect on on allowances negatively affected personal loan increase, they may still expect the circles to fall under the horizontal axis of determine 5. most effective the "other client" loan class indicates drastically lessen personal loan growth at CECL adopters following CECL adoption. besides the fact that children, as discussed prior to now, conclusions in accordance with comparisons of different customer loans between both sorts of banks may still be interpreted with warning.
typical, this evaluation does not deliver giant proof that CECL affected personal loan growth regardless of the impact on allowances. One probability, is that the transition rule sufficiently offset CECL's affect on allowances for each type of personal loan, cautioned via supplemental analysis (Appendix desk A.1 Panel C), and banks factored this advantage into their operational choices right through the unheard of time of stress.
CECL adopters' personal loan loss provisioning turned into tremendously more aware of the dramatic adjustments in financial outlook that passed off within the COVID-19 pandemic. in addition, the transition rule carried out well in about neutralizing the combination capital influence of CECL on adopters.
We extra explored the have an impact on of CECL on lending. On this factor, they interpret the restricted proof with caution. CECL has the abilities to cut back lending cyclicality when it acts as a precautionary measure, leading to banks building allowances as credit hazards regularly build in the late degrees of the credit cycle. In distinction, the sharp alternate in the economic outlook throughout the COVID-19 adventure became unlike any other credit score cycle in modern timesâ€”happening devoid of and unbiased of any buildup of credit score chance. As such, it's problematic to assess the cyclicality qualities of CECL. in addition, the colossal fiscal and fiscal coverage responses throughout the pandemic additionally make it hard to generalize these consequences to a greater ordinary credit score cycle. Regardless, their analysis provides little proof of an association between CECL's have an effect on on allowances and mortgage boom across distinctive loan kinds.
table A.1 items the consequences of the regressions akin to the equations in the "CECL have an impact on on Lending" section. Panel A covers the regressions used to estimate CECL's have an effect on on allowances, and Panel B covers regressions of CECL's impact on lending. The values of $$\beta_p$$ are pronounced in the first row. each and every column corresponds to the outcomes received for a particular loan classification. besides the results discussed above, the controls for delinquency costs display that better delinquency quotes are frequently linked to lessen lending growth and better allowances.
In Panel C, they verify even if CECL has had an influence on allowances after accounting for the have an impact on of an offset to the capital impact of the allowances. specially, because the transition rule provides a capital offset to neutralize 25 p.c of (put up-adoption) allowance raises while the usage of CECL, they modify allowances of transition rule users via multiplying the allowance-to-loan ratio after CECL adoption via 0.75. Panel C shows that not one of the estimates of affect to adjusted allowances are statistically colossal at a ten p.c level.
table A.1 - Regression Estimates of the have an effect on of CECL on Allowances and personal loan growth, by using personal loan category
Panel A: personal loan growth
commercialOther consumerCommercial RE
CECL Adopter X submit-2019
30-Day Delinquency rate (pp)
ninety-Day Delinquency expense (pp)
Non-Accrual price (pp)
Panel B: Allowance/loan Ratio (pp)
advertisementOther consumerCommercial RE
CECL Adopter X post-2019
30-Day Delinquency expense (pp)
90-Day Delinquency expense (pp)
Non-Accrual price (pp)
Panel C: Allowance/mortgage Ratio â€“ Adjusted for Transition Rule (pp)
commercialOther consumerCommercial RE
CECL Adopter X publish-2019
30-Day Delinquency cost (pp)
ninety-Day Delinquency price (pp)
Non-Accrual price (pp)
Quarter, financial institution
Please cite this notice as:
Loudis, Bert , Sasha Pechenik, Ben Ranish, Cindy M. Vojtech, and Helen Xu (2021). "New Accounting Framework Faces Its First check: CECL throughout the Pandemic," FEDS Notes. Washington: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve gadget, December 03, 2021, https://doi.org/10.17016/2380-7172.3025.